Virginia Data Center Planning and Community Engagement Toolkit vs Orange County Secret Toolkit

Our beloved Governor's office has requested public input on a shiny new "Virginia Data Center Planning and Community Engagement Toolkit". They are soliciting input that talks earnestly about early, accessible, good-faith engagement and model disclosure templates.
Directly from the letter:
"The Toolkit is intended to help local leaders, stakeholders, and communities navigate data center development decisions in an informed, transparent, and structured manner."
Another bullet point from the primary topics the toolkit should include:
"Best practices for early, accessible, and good faith community engagement—before, during, and after review."
This is especially "rich" considering the secret and urgent data center recruitment campaign that Orange County staff, and the Board of Supervisors have been following for nearly three years. Orange County is practicing a more efficient toolkit, in complete secrecy:
Recruit the industry,
let industry shape the zoning rules,
shape the infrastructure around the recruitment,
select and market private parcels in a "sacrifice zone" complete with Supervisor guided site tours,
let the public discover the details through FOIA, lawsuits, and citizen speeches.
Pretty much the EXACT opposite of what our Governor is apparently intending. While we welcome the additional guidance from the Governor's office, especially on transparency, this reminds us of the old saying: "Closing the barn door after the horses have already bolted."
A few things Orange County could do to help gain the trust of the citizens in the current state of affairs:
Schedule a public meeting and give our citizens a full briefing and accounting of the secret data center recruitment campaign. No need to tell us exact company names, just use the same secret project names we've seen in FOIAs: Project White, Project Ascent, Project Volare, Project Arc, Project Jazz, Project Otto.
Provide a detailed accounting of time, citizen tax dollars and grant money spent in this recruitment effort.
Suspend your beloved Overlay Technology Zoning District and bring it back to the planning commission for re-work and public comment. Frankly a judge is going to nix the whole thing due to the improper way it was approved with no public comment after substantial changes. Save yourselves some time, tax dollars and use it to garner trust from your constituents.
Give a FULL accounting of what and when Orange County knew about the Valley Link transmission line by current and former county Supervisors, county staff, and any other county related commissions, associations, councils. The initial statements from Chair Mr. Nicol that the county found out at the same time as the citizens just aren't meshing with revealed FOIA documents.
Explain the role of the Virginia Economic Development Partnership, the Central Virginia Partnership for Economic Development and the central Virginia "Innovation Corridor" and their interactions with county staff on 'match making' efforts for hyper-scale data center development. Detail the last five years of Orange County tax dollars sent to any of these organizations.
Provide some convincing argument (other than just coincidence) that county actions in the hyper-scale data center recruitment campaign of nearly 9,000 acres in the District 4 sacrifice zone (east of Route 522 and north of Route 20) didn't align the proposed Valley Link 765KV routes with the very parcels the county has been secretly marketing. We are reminded that the Dominion representative, speaking at a March 24, 2026, presentation at Orange County High School, described the route-selection process as looking for “co-location opportunities” such as industrial areas or tech overlay districts. Whether the westward shove of Valley Link was “inadvertent” or the predictable result of marketing industrial-scale loads in a specific corner of the county is a valid question for which the citizens of this county deserve an answer. The current alignment with your marketed parcels is impossible to ignore.
The Orange County pattern is consistent. Recruitment conversations, site marketing, ordinance drafting, and infrastructure alignment occur first, almost all of it under confidentiality or with industry counsel "in the room". Disclosure, when it arrives, is frequently the product of FOIA, litigation, or a citizen who decides to speak anyway. The state’s new toolkit emphasizes the exact opposite: engagement “before” review.
Eastern Orange residents can be forgiven for noticing that the transformers, the substations, and the ordinance language all seem to have found their way to the same corner of the map while the Board has consistently said that there are no applications and that nothing has really happened yet.
The Governors request for input to the toolkit invites all localities to contribute, as well as residents. Given the experiences here in Orange County, we will certainly contribute to question 7 in section 4, although not in the way it is posed, asking for successes, we have direct experience with a worst case example. Here is the premise of the question:
7. Community engagement: What examples or case studies demonstrate successful community engagement strategies associated with data center development or other major economic development projects?
a. What practices helped foster early, accessible, transparent, and good-faith engagement, including the timing and frequency of engagement, identification of stakeholders, methods for sharing information and gathering feedback, and coordination between localities and developers?
b. What should be the role of local representatives, industry, and other stakeholders in community engagement efforts in leading engagements and community negotiations?
c. What lessons should the Toolkit incorporate to support meaningful and ongoing engagement throughout the project lifecycle?
Orange County citizens we think will have quite the volume of examples on what NOT to do for the questions posed. The deadline is Monday November 16th at 5pm. In the PDF below at the top, click the 'submission form' link and you'll be brought to a nice easy web page to submit your comments, how convenient. It's an easy 5-page read, enjoy it from the quiet of your porch before bulldozers arrive to build the hyper-scale data centers and 175ft transmission towers.



Comments